Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

First home NAS for beginner

#1
Question 
Hey ! I've been reading and watching tons of information about NASes for over a month and still cannot decide. Luckily I got into this wonderful forum and I hope you guys can help me.

I'm a regular home user, have a lot of photos, movies, ISO files etc, completely running out of space on my PC. That's why I decided to get my first 2 bay NAS. 
My first choice was Synology DS224+however the more I read the less I know, therefore I will try to summarize my needs
I would like to have a plug & play device (therefore building my own is of the table, I'd rather go for complete devices).  My needs are:
  • autosyncing photos & movies from my android smartphones and having an access to them via dedicated android app
  • I have a Samsung TizenOS TV and would like to stream 4K movies from NAS to my TV via internet (I know that I'd have to sideload apps for TizenOS, but as well I have a chromecast 4k as backup). 
  • Access to NAS from my phone anywhere I am
  • NAS on HDDs however It would be nice if it had NVME slot as well. I will want to add some RAM as well
  • Running HomeAssistant 


Several devices caught me eye:
- Synology DS224+
- Synology DS723+ (however with this one I would have to wait for some discout as it exceeds my budget)
- UGREEN DXP2800 (This one is tempting, especially that has NVME slot and upgradable RAM, however I have no idea about stuff I've mentioned above and security of this one)
- AS3302T v2 DRIVESTOR 2 Pro Gen2 (This one as well was tempting however I read some negative comments about some random issues with connectivity, support and software)
- QNAP TS-264 (can't say much about this one - only heard it's not that beginner user-friendly)
- TERRAMASTER F2-424 (seems pretty decent but don't know much about software and other important stuff). 

As said before my first choice was DS224+ but I've been reading more and more negative news such as synology-only HDDs and the stuff they've removed over the years. I know it will impact future DS generations but who knows if suddenly they won't change their mind. That's why I was thinking if my future NAS should have a possibility to install TrueNAS just in case in the future and I know Synology blocked this option. 

May I ask for your advice ?   AS
Reply
#2
Great to see you doing your homework before diving into your first NAS — that’s the best way to avoid surprises!

Given your needs and preference for a ready-to-go device, here are some thoughts on the models you mentioned:

Synology DS224+

Very user-friendly with polished apps, great Android support, and strong ecosystem (including autosync apps and remote access).

NVMe slot for caching is a nice plus.

You can add some RAM, but it’s limited.

Downsides: Synology’s recent push for their own drives can be restrictive, but it’s mostly a warning for future-proofing. For now, many users still run third-party drives fine.

Synology’s software is rock solid for beginners, with good support for Home Assistant integrations.

Synology DS723+

More powerful, expandable RAM, and better for future needs.

But yeah, budget can be tight unless you find a good discount.

UGREEN DXP2800

Nice hardware with NVMe and RAM upgrades.

Software and ecosystem are less mature and can feel less polished compared to Synology or QNAP.

Security and app ecosystem not as proven yet.

AS3302T v2 / DRIVESTOR 2 Pro Gen2

Good value but some reports of connectivity issues and less reliable support make it less ideal for beginners.

QNAP TS-264

Powerful with many features, but the interface and setup can be intimidating for beginners.

Great for those who want to tinker a bit.

Terramaster F2-424

Decent and affordable, but software is simpler, and updates/support are less frequent.

My recommendation:
For a beginner focused on ease of use, stable apps for photo sync, and streaming, Synology DS224+ is still one of the best picks. It’s very beginner-friendly and has the ecosystem you want. The concerns about Synology drives are something to keep an eye on but won’t affect your experience immediately.

If you want more power and future-proofing and can wait for a deal, the DS723+ is a nice step up.

If you want raw hardware value and don’t mind a less polished experience, QNAP TS-264 is solid.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)