Posts: 1,180
Threads: 1,181
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
1
We need a solution to store video for FCPX editing & video archive, 4 time machines and the occasional VM - we'd love to backup iOS devices also. We have a rack with 10GB switch (MikroTik CRS312-4C+8XG-RM), 1GB leased line + 6GB Netgear SXK80 mesh & M2 MBPs. Currently have 1x Seagate ST16000NM001G Exos X16 + 4x old 4TB WD Red NAS WD40EFAX that we'd like to use initially & swap out over time. We currently have 14TB & growing of mainly video on Dropbox, but we'd like a local copy. If not rack mount now we would like to later move this NAS to second building and use as high availability backup to a future rack mount unit - when funds permit. Torn between RS422+ (for DSM, SHR & Btrfs), QNAP TS-431XeU (for better hardware specs), DS923+ (best bits of RS422 & 331, but won't fit in rack) & DS1522+ (for increased capacity, but no NVMe Storage Pools & greater cost) or is there a better option?
Posts: 4,313
Threads: 2
Joined: Jun 2022
Reputation:
28
Given the specifications and requirements you have outlined, it looks like the Synology RS422+ could be the best option for you. The RS422+ comes with Synology DSM software, which includes SHR (Synology Hybrid RAID), high availability, and an active backup solution that supports both Mac and other operating systems. Additionally, the Drive app will allow you to backup your iOS devices and the NAS also supports Time Machine backups.
While the QNAP TS-431XeU may have better hardware, the software might not be as good for your needs. The NVMe volumes would be great for video editing and virtual machines, but you could also install SSDs in the HDD bays to gain SATA speeds, which would be a good alternative.
The DS923+ may have the best features of the RS422+ and the 331 series, but it won't fit in your rack. The DS1522+ has increased capacity, but doesn't include NVMe storage pools and is more expensive.
It's recommended to consider only the Plus series models, as the XS series models are meant for serious virtual machines.
In conclusion, the Synology RS422+ seems to be the best fit for your needs given its features, compatibility with your current setup, and cost-effectiveness.
