+- ASK NC (https://ask.nascompares.com)
+-- Forum: Q&A (https://ask.nascompares.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: Before you buy Q&A (https://ask.nascompares.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=2)
+--- Thread: Upgrading QNAP NAS (/showthread.php?tid=9508)
Upgrading QNAP NAS - Shinta - 06-23-2023
I currently have a TS-431P with a TL-D800C expansion unit. I am looking to move my TS-431P into a standalone unit and replace it with another QNAP NAS. Ideally I would like a new QNAP NAS that can work with my TL-D800C but also supports SATA expansion units for later expansions. I would settle for a 4 bay unit but would prefer a 6 or even 8 bay NAS.
When doing a recent live migration I noted that it appeared that the bottle neck was my CPU as the resource manager showed it at near 100%. I understanding doing a live migration on a RAID6 means it had to recalculate parity. I always encrypt my volumes if that impacts the choice.
As for my use case, it is fairly straight forward. A single user (me) uses it to hold a number of RAW images and large video files. For my RAW images I use software that catalogues these on my PC and as a result, have previews of these images stored in a cache located on a drive local to my PC. I do not believe that having an SSD cache on the NAS would be of any use.
I do not use anything like PLEX or the media server components. Whilst my current network only supports Gigabit speeds, I would like to to upgrade it in the near future to either 2.5 Gbit or 10 Gbit.
RE: Upgrading QNAP NAS - ed - 06-27-2023
Yes, you could migrate to a bigger NAS such as 73A or even 74 series model https://www.qnap.com/en-uk/product/?conditions=0-7,0-6,3-3,5-1
This expansion will work with any NAS
Compatibility list https://view.publitas.com/qnap-1/tl-usb-jbod-compatibility_cht/page/1
Faster CPU will alow faster RAID rebuilding and 10GbE speeds.
RE: Upgrading QNAP NAS - Shinta - 06-27-2023
(06-27-2023, 02:42 PM)ed Wrote: Yes, you could migrate to a bigger NAS such as 73A or even 74 series model https://www.qnap.com/en-uk/product/?conditions=0-7,0-6,3-3,5-1
This expansion will work with any NAS
Compatibility list https://view.publitas.com/qnap-1/tl-usb-jbod-compatibility_cht/page/1
Faster CPU will alow faster RAID rebuilding and 10GbE speeds.
Thank you for taking the time to reply.
RE: Upgrading QNAP NAS - Shinta - 07-16-2023
(06-27-2023, 02:42 PM)ed Wrote: Yes, you could migrate to a bigger NAS such as 73A or even 74 series model https://www.qnap.com/en-uk/product/?conditions=0-7,0-6,3-3,5-1
This expansion will work with any NAS
Compatibility list https://view.publitas.com/qnap-1/tl-usb-jbod-compatibility_cht/page/1
Faster CPU will alow faster RAID rebuilding and 10GbE speeds.
I watched some more of your videos relating to NASs including one going over CPUs and one comparing QTS(ext4) vs QTS Hero (ZFS). When comparing QTS to QTS hero I think I should stay with QTS so that I can easily expanded my current array by adding a single disks. As such, I want to minimise potential RAID rebuild and scrubbing times.
I lowered my requirement for 10Gbe as I saw many of the units have PCI expansions so I can always purchase an expansion card and install that separately later.
My current 4-bay NAS is very underpowered with only 1GB of RAM and an ARM CPU. When scrubbing, I notice the CPU maintain around 100% CPU utilisation which suggests that the CPU is the bottleneck.
Follow up questions.
1. Assuming I remain with QTS and a RAID6 array with an expansion unit, will the CPU remain the bottle neck when scrubbing/rebuilding or at what point does the CPU no longer become a bottle neck?
2. I saw some of the QNAP CPUs have a higher thread and core count but lower clock speed than others. I am not sure how QNAPs are programmed but can they take advantage of the increased core count when scrubbing or would clock speed be better to prioritise?
3. Some the NASs I was considering have the CPUs listed below. I ordered them in the cheapest to most expensive units I was considering. I was wondering how I can determine the impact the CPU will have on scrubbing times. For example, would a system with a Intel Core i3 8100T 3.1 GHz (Quad-Core) cut scrubbing times in half compared to one running with a Intel® Celeron® N5095 4-core/4-thread processor, burst up to 2.9 GHz? I assume there is diminishing returns which is why I am trying to balance the price vs the power of the CPU.
Intel® Celeron® N5095 4-core/4-thread processor, burst up to 2.9 GHz
Intel® Celeron® J4125 4-core/4-thread processor, burst up to 2.7 GHz
AMD Ryzen™ Embedded V1500B 4-core/8-thread 2.2 GHz processor
AMD R-Series RX-421ND 4-core 2.1 GHz processor (Turbo Core to 3.4 GHz)
ZhaoXin KX-U6580 8-core 2.5GHz processor
Intel Core i3 8100T 3.1 GHz (Quad-Core)
Intel® Xeon® D-1622 4-core/8-thread processor, up to 3.2 GHz
Intel® Core™ i5 Processor 6 core 1.7GHz, burst up to 3.3GHz
Intel® Core™ i5-12400 6-core/12-thread Processor, burst up to 4.4 GHz
Thank you again.