+- ASK NC (https://ask.nascompares.com)
+-- Forum: Q&A (https://ask.nascompares.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: Before you buy Q&A (https://ask.nascompares.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=2)
+--- Thread: NAS upgrade (/showthread.php?tid=11454)
NAS upgrade - Enquiries - 11-26-2024
Hello,
I actually own a Asustor AS5202T and 1 extenion unit that I use as mainly as movies storage with HDD in RAID1.
I want to upgrade for a new NAS
I'm actually looking for the new Lokerstor 10 gen 3 that is about to be released.
I need at least a 10 HDD bays NAS
I don't need HDMI output, I use a dedicated media player
Graphic card is not a high priority, I don't use plex right now
I need a 10G ethernet
I might use it for home assistant in the futur
pros : easy migration / I already own an extension for the future
cons : ?
Is there another option I should look at that will be better ?
Thank you,
Lugburzguul
RE: NAS upgrade - ed - 11-28-2024
The Asustor Lockerstor 10 Gen 3 is a solid choice if you're already familiar with Asustor and have an extension unit. It's a strong candidate for your needs, but there are some other options worth considering, especially if you want the best future-proofing and flexibility for upgrades like adding a GPU.
Pros of the Lockerstor 10 Gen 3:
Easy Migration: Since you're already using an Asustor system, migrating your data will be smoother.
10G Ethernet: Future-proof connectivity for faster transfer speeds, which is crucial for your large storage needs.
Expansion: You have the option to easily add an extension unit if you need more storage down the line.
Cons:
Limited software flexibility: Asustor's software ecosystem isn’t as feature-rich or polished as some of the competition, like Synology or QNAP.
No ECC RAM support: For long-term data integrity and reliability, ECC RAM support is a big plus. The Lockerstor series doesn’t offer this.
Potential future upgradeability limitations: While the system is solid, certain features (like future CPU upgrades) are not as flexible compared to other high-end NAS models.
Alternative Recommendations:
QNAP TS-73A or TS-74 Series:
These models are fantastic choices if you're looking for expandability and future-proofing. They offer 10G Ethernet and PCIe slots for adding a GPU or other expansion cards (like additional network cards or even NVMe storage).
They are equipped with a powerful AMD Ryzen CPU, making them suitable for tasks like gaming, virtualization, or media transcoding if you plan to run demanding applications.
The QTS or QuTS Hero software offers a robust feature set, including virtual machines, Docker support, and extensive network options.